Introduction
In today's globalized economy, multinational corporations often establish subsidiaries in various countries to expand their operations and take advantage of favorable business environments and tax haven countries. However, this practice has given rise to challenges in international tax regulation, leading to additional anti-deferral regimes that have dramatically expanded in recent years, mainly attributable to the enactment of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act in 2017 (TCJA) under the Trump administration. The TCJA introduced a significant overhaul to the U.S. tax landscape, ushering in new requirements and categories of foreign income inclusions that have notably affected U.S. shareholders by creating the concepts of Controlled Foreign Corporations (CFCs) and Passive Foreign Investment Companies (PFICs). This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of CFCs and their implications for businesses to ensure compliance and navigate this complex world.
A Controlled Foreign Corporation (“CFC”) refers to any foreign corporation if more than fifty percent (50%) of either (i) the total combined voting power of all classes of stock entitled to vote, (ii) or the total value of the stock of such corporation, is owned, or considered as owned by applying the rules of ownership, by United States shareholders on any day during the taxable year of such foreign corporation. A U.S. Person (i.e., a U.S. citizen) is a U.S. Shareholder if the U.S. Person, directly or indirectly, owns 10% or more of the foreign corporation's total voting power or stock value. The primary purpose of the CFC rules is to prevent the deferral of foreign source income or tax evasion by imposing taxation on certain income generated by foreign subsidiaries that may otherwise escape taxation in the country in which they were organized.
Entity Classification
When a domestic entity has a significant influence over a foreign corporation, the income of that foreign corporation or CFC becomes subject to taxation in the United States. When establishing a business entity, deciding on the appropriate U.S. income tax treatment is essential, also known as its tax classification. The U.S. Internal Revenue Code (“IRC”) utilizes the entity classification rules commonly known as "check-the-box" regulations. These rules allow taxpayers to elect a specific tax classification for their foreign entities, determining whether they will be treated as corporations, partnerships, or disregarded entities for U.S. income tax purposes. Certain entities operate as pass-through entities, meaning their income, losses, and credits pass through to their owners and are taxed and reported at the owner's level, regardless of whether the funds are distributed. In contrast, other entities, including corporations, are liable for income tax at the entity level. Subsequently, when income is distributed to the owner (shareholder), it incurs taxation at the owner level and must be reported on the owner’s personal income tax return.
Ownership and Control
CFC rules depend almost entirely on the concept of ownership and control. Section 958 of the IRC outlines regulations for determining the stock ownership in a corporation concerning provisions from Sections 951 to 965, which encompass the Subpart F income rules, which will be discussed below. These rules play a crucial role in identifying U.S. shareholders who are subject to the recognition of Subpart F income. Essentially, it provides guidelines to ascertain the ownership structure of a corporation, helping to determine which shareholders fall under the purview of Subpart F, which addresses the taxation of certain types of foreign income for U.S. taxpayers. There are the so-called attribution rules. The attribution rules of stock ownership, as outlined in the IRC, establish guidelines for attributing ownership of corporate stock to individuals or entities and are summarized as follows:
- Direct Ownership: Stock ownership is attributed directly to an individual or entity if they own shares in their own right.
- Family Attribution: Ownership of certain family members, including spouses, parents, children, and siblings, is attributed to an individual.
- Constructive Ownership: Ownership can be constructively attributed based on certain relationships and circumstances. For example, stock owned by a partnership, estate, trust, or corporation may be attributed to its partners, beneficiaries, or shareholders.
- Entity Attribution: Stock owned by an entity, such as a corporation, may be attributed to its shareholders based on their ownership percentage.
- Option Attribution: An individual may be considered an owner of stock if they hold an option to acquire the stock.
These attribution rules help determine the aggregate stock ownership for various tax purposes, particularly in the context of Subpart F income, where the identification of U.S. shareholders is critical.
Subpart F Income
Subpart F income refers to a foreign income category subject to immediate U.S. taxation, even if it hasn't been distributed to U.S. shareholders. Enforced under the IRC's Subpart F rules, this provision aims to prevent U.S. taxpayers from deferring taxes by retaining certain types of income in CFCs. Subpart F income includes passive income such as dividends, interest, royalties, and certain gains. The U.S. shareholders of a CFC are required to include their share of Subpart F income in their individual or corporate tax returns, ensuring that such income is taxed currently rather than being deferred until repatriation, which occurs when such earnings, profits, and investments are brought back to the U.S.
More importantly, the Subpart F inclusion often triggers the availability of an indirect foreign tax credit. This credit is designed to alleviate the potential double taxation concern, allowing U.S. shareholders to offset some or all of the U.S. tax liability associated with the Subpart F inclusion with foreign taxes paid or accrued by the CFC. Consequently, the interaction between Subpart F income and the foreign tax credit provisions aims to strike a balance between ensuring the taxation of certain foreign income in the U.S. and preventing undue double taxation for U.S. shareholders with ownership interests in CFCs.
Foreign Tax Credit
If you have incurred foreign taxes in a foreign country or U.S. possession and are liable for U.S. taxation on the corresponding income, you can claim a tax credit or an itemized deduction for those foreign taxes. The credit applies for foreign taxes imposed by a foreign country or U.S. possession, typically covering income, war profits, and excess profits taxes. By choosing the credit, the foreign income taxes directly decrease your U.S. tax liability. Alternatively, these foreign income taxes reduce your U.S. taxable income if taken as a deduction. Generally, opting for the tax credit is advantageous as it directly lowers your U.S. tax liability in most situations.
IRS Reporting
If you are a U.S. person of a CFC, it is mandatory to file an annual report using IRS Form 5471, Information Return of U.S. Persons With Respect To Certain Foreign Corporations. This comprehensive form requires submitting various details, including information on U.S. citizens serving as shareholders, directors, and officers. Additionally, a listing of all U.S. shareholders along with their stock holdings, details about the CFC's classes of stock and outstanding shares, and the company’s financial statements for the tax year.
It's important to note that the corporation itself is responsible for filing Form 5471. However, each U.S. shareholder, director, or officer meeting the 50% criterion must file a separate form individually. This individual report encompasses details of each U.S. person's income derived from dividends, investments, and other sources related to the foreign corporation.
Conclusion
CFCs pose both challenges and opportunities for multinational businesses and individuals. By understanding the nuances of CFC rules and engaging in strategic tax planning, companies can successfully navigate the complexities of the global tax landscape. CFCs, with their intricate rules and reporting requirements, underscore the need for meticulous compliance and tax planning to avoid unintended tax consequences and/or the possibility of an audit by the IRS. Staying informed of evolving regulations is important as international tax policies continue to adapt to the evolving nature of global commerce. In this landscape, informed decision-making and proactive tax strategies are indispensable for businesses and individuals alike seeking to thrive in our global economy. Professional advice remains a cornerstone in ensuring compliance with the complexities of these rules, safeguarding businesses and individuals from unintended pitfalls and optimizing their tax positions within the framework of U.S. tax laws.
Written by: Atty. Sebastián J. Sánchez Esteve
___________________________
This Newsletter has been prepared for information purposes only. It is not intended as, and does not constitute, or should be construed, as legal advice or solicitation of any prospective client. An attorney-client relationship with BIO Counselors at Law LLC (BIO) may not be created by reading or responding to this Newsletter. Such a relationship may be established solely through an express written engagement with BIO.
